AI-generated text has become more popular these days as the development of this service is getting better and better. It provides various ideas, topics, and themes we can think of. However, the accuracy of the information might be slightly off, at least in current condition. Having said that, I want to see which one provides the better result on this particular topic I love, Indonesian Football.
I ask ChatGPT and Bard to give me the Indonesian all-time best eleven, and here's the result.
Bard Indonesian football national team's all-time best eleven:
Goalkeeper: Kurnia Sandy (1969-1982)
Defenders:
Iswadi Idris (1967-1980)
Anwar Ujang (1975-1986)
Robby Darwis (1985-1998)
Benny Dolo (1979-1996)
Midfielders:
Abdul Kadir (1965-1979)
Kurniawan Dwi Yulianto (1991-2003)
Ponaryo Astaman (1999-2010)
Forwards:
Bambang Pamungkas (1999-2014)
Boaz Solossa (2004-2021)
Rochy Putiray (1999-2011)
ChatGPT squad
Goalkeeper: Nurdin Halid - A legendary Indonesian goalkeeper known for his agility and shot-stopping abilities.
Right Back: Benny Dollo - A versatile defender who played a significant role in the national team during the 1980s and 1990s.
Center Back: Robby Darwis - A strong and composed center back who captained the Indonesian national team in the late 1970s and early 1980s.
Center Back: Charis Yulianto - An iconic defender who represented Indonesia for over a decade, known for his leadership and defensive skills.
Left Back: Maman Abdurahman - A talented left back who was a key figure in the national team during the 1990s and early 2000s.
Defensive Midfielder: Ponaryo Astaman - A midfield anchor known for his defensive prowess and ability to control the game from a deep position.
Central Midfielder: Bambang Pamungkas - A legendary Indonesian footballer who played as an attacking midfielder, known for his goal-scoring ability and creativity.
Central Midfielder: Fachri Husaini - A skilled midfielder who contributed significantly to the national team during the 1970s and 1980s.
Right Winger: Kurniawan Dwi Yulianto - A highly talented winger who possessed excellent dribbling skills and played a crucial role in Indonesia's success in the 1990s.
Striker: Soetjipto Soentoro - A prolific goalscorer who represented Indonesia during the 1960s and is considered one of the greatest Indonesian footballers of all time.
Left Winger: Boaz Solossa - A skillful and versatile winger who has been a key player for the national team in recent years, known for his speed and goal-scoring ability.
Both actually provide a decent result with the same formation of 433.
However, some names are likely mistaken as a player on the list. For example, Nurdin Halid on ChatGPT and Benny Doll on ChatGPT and Bard. Both names played roles in Indonesian football, but I don't think they had a professional football career, or at least I don't think so. And one worth noticing is some players are not in their natural position on both results.
So, which list do you like better?
Comments